Election Challenge Questions Nicole Mitchell’s Eligibility for Woodbury City Council

Nov 19, 2026

Four Woodbury voters are asking a Washington County judge to disqualify former state Sen. Nicole Mitchell from serving on the Woodbury City Council, arguing that her ongoing felony sentence makes her ineligible to hold elected office under Minnesota law.

Mitchell finished 101 votes ahead of the third-place candidate in the November 3 election, earning one of two at-large council seats.

The Upper Midwest Law Center filed the election contest on behalf of Kelly Fenton, Eric Lipman, Dwight Dorau and Tamara Gentry.

Mitchell was convicted in 2025 of first-degree burglary and possession of burglary tools. Her 21-month prison sentence was stayed for five years, through September 2030, with the remainder potentially served on supervised probation after jail time.

UMLC argues that Minnesota law does not permit convicted felons who are on probation, parole, or work release to hold elected office.

 “Minnesota statutes distinguish between the right to vote and the right to hold public office,” said Nicholas J. Nelson, Senior Appellate Counsel at UMLC. “The Legislature restored voting rights to certain individuals who are no longer incarcerated, but it did not restore every civil right before a felony sentence is discharged. Our clients are asking the court to enforce that distinction.” Nelson added, “In addition to that, constitutional problems with the felon-voting statute mean that it cannot support any right for felons to hold office.”

The contest asks the court to disqualify Mitchell, invalidate any election certificate issued to her and declare the council seat vacant.

“Election laws and eligibility requirements only matter if they are enforced consistently,” said Dr. Douglas P. Seaton, Founder and President of UMLC. “This case is bigger than one candidate or one election. The rule of law requires public officials to follow the same legal standards that apply to everyone else.”

The case was filed in Washington County District Court, Tenth Judicial District, and seeks the expedited review provided under Minnesota election law.

Read the Notice of Election Contest.