The Upper Midwest Law Center is challenging a Minnesota law that discriminates against religious belief and practice by withholding generally available K-12 education tax benefits to Minnesota families solely because of those families’ desire to teach their children according to their religious faith.
UMLC, together with Alliance Defending Freedom (ADF), filed the case on behalf of Minnesota fathers Nathan Colestock and Joseph Osburn against Minnesota Commissioner of Revenue Paul Marquart. Both families educate their children through homeschool instruction, Christian co-ops, and other programs rooted in their faith.
Minnesota offers a K-12 Education Deduction and Credit to help families offset expenses such as tutoring, instructional materials, and enrichment classes. But state law excludes materials, fees, and instruction used to teach religious beliefs.
For Colestock and Osburn, separating faith from education is not an option. Their sincerely held beliefs call them to teach every subject, including math, science and history through a Christian worldview. As a result, they cannot claim benefits that would otherwise be available to them without denying the religious nature of their children’s education.
“Minnesota can decide whether to offer educational tax benefits, but once it does, it cannot treat families differently simply because they choose to teach their children according to their religious faith,” said Brent Robbins, UMLC Senior Counsel for Religious Liberty. “The Constitution does not allow the state to force parents to choose between living out their beliefs and receiving a generally available public benefit.”
The lawsuit argues that Minnesota’s religious exclusion violates the First Amendment’s Free Exercise Clause, the Minnesota Constitution’s protection of freedom of conscience, and parents’ Fourteenth Amendment right to direct the upbringing and education of their children.
UMLC and ADF also point to the U.S. Supreme Court precedent holding that states cannot exclude otherwise eligible recipients from public benefits solely because of religious exercise. The complaint argues Minnesota does exactly that by treating comparable secular educational expenses more favorably than religious ones.
“Parents should not receive fewer protections because they choose to educate their children according to their faith,” said Dr. Douglas P. Seaton, founder and president of UMLC. “UMLC exists to challenge government policies that cross constitutional lines and defend the fundamental freedoms of religious liberty and parental rights.”
Colestock, a Minnesota pastor and father of four, qualifies for both the Education Credit and Deduction but has not claimed them because of the religious nature of his children’s education. Osburn, a father of six, qualifies for the Education Deduction but likewise has not claimed it because doing so would conflict with his beliefs.
The families are asking the court to declare Minnesota’s religious exclusion unconstitutional and prohibit the state from conditioning K-12 education tax benefits on families not exercising their religious beliefs.
Read the complaint filed in Minnesota Tax Court, Regular Division.
